Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you buy through them I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. I only recommend tools I use on real client stores.
Shopify’s own free Product Reviews app has been discontinued, so every store now needs a third-party review app. I’ve installed most of the popular ones on client stores. The right one depends less on features and more on your store size, how visual your products are, and how much JavaScript you’re willing to add to every product page.
In this article
Quick comparison
| App | Best for | Free plan | Paid from* |
|---|---|---|---|
| Judge.me | Most stores, budget, speed | Yes | $15/mo (Awesome) |
| Loox | Photo and video reviews (fashion, beauty) | No | $12.99/mo |
| Okendo | Premium and Shopify Plus brands | No | $19/mo |
| Yotpo | Larger brands wanting reviews + loyalty + SMS | Yes (limited) | Varies by plan |
*Prices from the apps’ listings at the time of writing. Check the Shopify App Store before you install, as plans change often.
1. Judge.me: my default for most stores
Judge.me’s free plan covers what most new stores need: unlimited reviews, photo and video reviews, review request emails and Google star ratings in search results. The paid Awesome plan adds integrations, Q&A and more customization at a flat price that doesn’t grow with your order count. It’s also one of the lighter apps on page speed.
Pick it if: you want something that works well, costs little and stays out of the way.
2. Loox: best for photo and video reviews
Loox is built around visual reviews: it asks customers for photos and videos and displays them in galleries that sell well for fashion, beauty and home products. It also bundles referral and upsell features. There’s no free plan, and pricing rises with volume.
Pick it if: your product looks great in customers’ photos and visuals drive the sale.
3. Okendo: best for premium and Plus brands
Okendo focuses on structured review data: customer attributes such as size, skin type or fit, which you can use for filtering and marketing. It integrates deeply with Klaviyo and other tools that established brands use.
Pick it if: you’re an established brand that wants reviews as a data source, not just stars.
4. Yotpo: best all-in-one for larger brands
Yotpo combines reviews with loyalty, SMS and other retention products. There’s a free tier, but its strength is the paid suite for brands that want one vendor for several retention tools.
Pick it if: you’re mid-market and want reviews and loyalty under one roof.
How to choose in 30 seconds
- New store or tight budget: Judge.me free.
- Visual products, photo reviews matter: Loox.
- Established brand, rich data and Klaviyo: Okendo.
- Want reviews + loyalty + SMS together: Yotpo.
Things that matter more than features
- Page speed. Some review widgets add 100KB+ of JavaScript to every product page. Test your product page speed before and after installing.
- Review request timing. Send the request after delivery, not after purchase. Most apps let you set the delay.
- Google star ratings. Make sure the app outputs review schema, and that your SEO app doesn’t output a second, conflicting one.
- Easy exit. Check the app can export your reviews. Most can import from competitors, so you’re not locked in.
Building a new store? Start Shopify for $1/month for 3 months and install Judge.me free on day one.
FAQ
Does Shopify have a free built-in review app?
Not anymore. Shopify discontinued its Product Reviews app, so you need a third-party app. Judge.me’s free plan is the closest replacement.
Can I move reviews between apps?
Yes. Most review apps import from Judge.me, Loox, Yotpo, Okendo and CSV files, so switching later is straightforward.
Do reviews help SEO?
They add fresh, unique text to product pages and can show star ratings in Google results, which improves click-through rate.
